info@biomedres.us   +1 (720) 414-3554
  One Westbrook Corporate Center, Suite 300, Westchester, IL 60154, USA

Biomedical Journal of Scientific & Technical Research

May, 2021, Volume 36, 1, pp 28145-28153

Review Article

Review Article

Development of a Healthy Lifestyle Module to Improve Mental Health in Adolescent Students: Protocol of a Randomized Controlled Trial

Esra Tajik*1, Nasrin Omidvar2, Mohammadreza Mohammadi3 and Behnam Rashidkhani4

Author Affiliations

1Psychiatry and psychology research center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences and Department of Community Nutrition, National Nutrition and Food Technology Research Institute, Faculty of Nutrition and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Iran

2Department of Community Nutrition, National Nutrition and Food Technology Research Institute, Faculty of Nutrition and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Iran

3Psychiatry and psychology research center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences

4Department of Community Nutrition, Faculty of Nutrition and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Tehran, Iran

Received: May 15, 2021 | Published: May 24, 2021

Corresponding author: Esra Tajik, Psychiatry and psychology research center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences and Department of Community Nutrition, National Nutrition and Food Technology Research Institute, Faculty of Nutrition and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Iran

DOI: 10.26717/BJSTR.2021.36.005787

Abstract

The current study aimed to determine if a lifestyle-based intervention program could improve the mental health of adolescent students. This study is a randomized controlled trial in eleven sessions among 370 adolescents with no severe score of general health questionnaire. Primary outcome assessment at pre-, post- and three-month followup tests includes general health score and the secondary outcomes include changes in eating habit, physical activity and stress management skills using healthy lifestyle questionnaire, eating behavior, daily activity, coping inventory for stressful situations and general health questionnaire. The findings of the current study will be used as a starting point of incessant, regular lifestyle education for adolescents, and for researchers and educators to improve the health and well-being globally.

Keywords: Healthy Lifestyle; Healthy Eating; Mental Health; Depression; Anxiety; Stress

Background

Adolescence is a critical transitional period of life, which is characterized by critical and serious physical and psychological changes [1,2]. According to the United Nations Children’s Fund [3], there are 1.2 billion adolescents (16% of the world’s population) in the world. The Iranian population with an average annual growth rate of 1.07% increased to over 81 million by 2018, there were then 12.3 million adolescents, about 15% of the country’s population [4]. Lifestyle diseases such as metabolic syndrome, cancer, and mental diseases are diseases of civilization and the main cause of death in the world [5-8]. Among the causes of lifestyle diseases and poor mental health, factors such as unhealthy eating habits, low physical activity, coping weakness, and chronic psychological stress are some of the major ones [9,10,11]. Many of these critical conditions in adulthood, such as lifestyle diseases, some other chronic diseases, unhealthy eating habits and low physical activity are rooted in the adolescence and can lead to illness or premature death later in life [12,13]. Lifestyle recommendations are also associated with mental health in children and adolescents [14]. Emphasizing lifestyle recommendations such as diet, physical activity, sedentary behavior and sleep in children and adolescents may reduce the future burden of mental illness [14]. Globally, the prevalence of mental health problem is 10-20% in children and adolescents [15]. In the developing countries, 7.9% to 15.7% of adolescents suffer from mental disorders [15,16,17].

The rise in the number of adolescents with mental disorders has become a major concern over the recent decades [18,19]. As a result, there are needs for not only psychotherapeutic and pharmacological treatments, but also a variety of special preventive services such as educational interventions [20-22].

Intervention

Unhealthy lifestyle factors such as unhealthy eating, physical inactivity and poor stress management skills can contribute to mental health disorders, like depression, stress and anxiety [23]. Mental health disorders affect many adolescents [24]. The current research states the potential of lifestyle improvement to improve mental health status. Generally, despite the presence of effective approaches to reduce mental disorders, they are highly neglected [25]. Evidence in developed and developing countries has shown the effect of healthy lifestyle interventions on improving mental health status [26,27]. Therefore, there is a need to design and implement lifestyle change interventions targeted at adolescents to improve their mental and general health. In this regard, psychosocial and nutritional status and their determinants need to be evaluated and considered before planning or starting any strategy involving adolescents. Overall, the three top components of healthy lifestyle include healthy diet, physical activity and stress management which have often been neglected [28-30]. In Iran, healthy lifestyle education is very new, and there is a lack of systematic lifestyle training for adolescents. The lack of lifestyle-based education places Iranian adolescents at a higher risk of behavioral and mental problems such as stress, anxiety and depression [31]. Based on our knowledge, the present study is one of the first attempts in the country to implement a healthy lifestyle education intervention aim to improve mental health. Findings of the current research are hoped to be used by health care professionals and practitioners, policymakers and teachers to promote healthier lifestyle by not only psychological parameters but nutrition and physical activities in the adolescent community.

Theoretical Framework

The lifestyle behavior needs to be fully explicated within a theoretical context. Few studies have applied behavioral change theories on children and/or adolescents for promoting a healthy lifestyle [32,33]. Among the available theories, those with fewer factors and containing motivational factor are considered as more appropriate models for adolescents [34,35]. The Information- Motivation-Behavioral skill (IMB) model moves beyond the Health Belief Model and Social Cognitive Theory by suggesting that information, motivation, and behavioral skills are the primary individual level determinants of adopting preventive behaviors [36]. The IMB model has been tested for the prediction of healthy lifestyle behaviors, physical activity and dietary intake in adolescents [32]. Based on the Information-Motivation-Behavioral skill model, people who are well informed, motivated to act and practice, and have behavioral skills will maintain health-promoting behaviors and experience proper health outcomes [34-36]. The present study using IMB model has developed an interventional program to improve mental health in adolescents. Within the framework of the model, improvement of knowledge, attitude and behavior for healthy eating, physical activity and stress management skills were emphasized [37]. The theoretical framework of study based on IMB model.

Design and Method Strength

Aim and Hypotheses

The current study aims to develop a healthy lifestyle (healthy eating, physical activity and stress management skills) education module to improve mental health among student adolescents in Tehran, Iran.

The main research hypotheses are as follows:

a) There is a significant difference in scores of knowledge, attitude and behavior for healthy diet, physical activity and stress management skills among adolescents in the intervention group compared to control group.

b) There is a significant difference in general health score between the intervention and control groups at the end of the intervention.

Study Design

The present study is a single blinded randomized controlled trial (RCT) using a multi-stage sampling method. This RCT included a pre-, post- and three-month follow-up test presents schematic overview of the study steps.

Participants

The target population of the study is girl and boy students of high schools in three different socioeconomic districts of Tehran city, including deprived, mid-level and prosperous districts. Students aged 13-15 years who are able to write and read and are from public schools will be included to the study. Students will be excluded from the study if they have severe emotional distress (based on general health questionnaire) or those with diagnosed psychiatric illnesses; and also, students who refuse to fill the consent form.

Sample Size Calculation

Calculation of sample size for the current RCT is based on Aday and Cornelius [39], where n is sample size in each group; Z1-α and Z1-β equal 1.96 and 0.84, respectively. P1 (19.1%) and P2 (3.2%) according to previous study by Eslami et al. [40] are proportion of stress status between intervention and control groups after an interventional study. After calculating the “n”, adding 20% for non-responding and enhancing by a coefficient of 1.2 for estimated design effect, the final sample size is 117 for each intervention and control groups.

Sampling Technique and Recruitment

A Multi-Stage Sampling Frame is Applied Through the Following Steps: First, the list of districts of Tehran was taken from formal documents of the ministry of education in which districts are categorized based on their socioeconomic status into deprived, mid-level and prosperous. In the second step, 12 schools from the 3 levels of districts were randomly selected and in each selected district 2 boys’ schools and 2 girls’ schools were listed. Then schools were equally allocated into intervention and control groups based on the feasibility and permissiveness. Finally, a screening study will be conducted among 1200 students based on General Health Questionnaire (GHQ) and after consulting with the school principal and the teachers, one class in each school will be randomly selected to participate to the study. Respecting ethical issues and avoiding any inconvenience, students with the exclusion criteria will not be taken out of classes. Therefore, all the students in each class will take part in the study and in total almost 370 participants will fill the questionnaires at the pre-intervention stage.

Developing and Pilot Testing the Intervention

The educational package based on the IMB model was developed in Persian, comprising stress management, physical activity and healthy diet modules (11 sessions). The main teaching strategies include group discussion, debate, videos (animation), research book, health talk, musical exercise, relaxation activities, games and competition. The educational package was developed through highlighting the strength and minimizing the weakness of current existing modules in some other countries, including US [41-43], Iran [44], Malaysia [45-47], Hongkong [48] and etc. In the process of developing, the package was revised by a panel of health professionals (psychiatry, psychologist, and nutritionist) from Shahid Beheshti Medical science University (SBMU), Tehran University of Medical Sciences (TUMS), Ministry of Health, Ministry of Education and National Elites Foundation through a series of round tables.

Content Validity: The content of developed package was evaluated in terms of acceptability of the module such as title of the module, title of each session, appropriate level of content, reading level, design, graphic, activities (games and competitions), time and etc. Each item was assessed by health professionals, teachers and adolescent students ranging from poor (0) to very good (4) covering all aspects of the module.

Face Validity: The developed educational module was tested in a high school which will not be included in the main study. It was tested among 35 students for clarity of meaning, language, the flow of contents and the time needed for presenting. Each student signed a consent form before the beginning of educational sessions. In line with piloting the module, the pre-testing of the questionnaire set was conducted.

The final draft of healthy lifestyle educational module with 11 sessions (Table 1) was named as “TAVANA” which is the acronym of four words in Persian language. It stands for TA “Taghzieh salem” (healthy eating), V “Varzesh” (exercise), A “Aramesh: (calmness), NA “Nadaram stress” (no stress). The educational module is comprised of one session for “Introduction and Ice-breaking” and 10 sessions to cover the 3 main domains of healthy lifestyle, including stress management skills (knowing self, knowing stress situations, managing stressful situations, coping strategies and relaxation activity), physical activity (musical and stretching exercises and some educational games such as toxic ball) and healthy diet (balanced diet, my healthy plate, importance of main meals, fruits and vegetables).

Table 1: The content, activities and learning outcomes of the educational sessions.

The sessions will be held once per week for one hour in each intervention school. Each session starts with relaxation activities and finishes by Q&A and musical exercise. Researcher will make the rules to control the educational sessions and their discipline. The rules of attending classes will be reviewed for students at the beginning of each session. The required materials and stationeries will be provided and checked by research team before each session. No intervention will be conducted in the control group during data collection. The control group will receive the educational instruments and materials at the end of the study.

Measurements and Outcomes

Data will be collected by six, self-administered questionnaires to measure demographics, knowledge, attitude and practice for healthy lifestyle, healthy diet, physical activity and stress management skills including relaxation activities and coping.

The questionnaires were developed by the expert panel in Shahid Beheshti Medical Sciences University (SBMU) and Tehran University of Medical Sciences (TUMS). The questionnaire also was adapted from the previous study on healthy lifestyle by Tajik et al. [49] which was conducted among adolescents. The process of review and revising of the questionnaires was done considering the module content. Reliability and validity of the questionnaires were assessed through evaluating their face and content validity, as well as internal consistency.

A. The Study Questionnaires are as Follows:

Demographic Questionnaire: age, gender, ethnicity, household size, monthly household income, parental educational level, parental occupation and the menarche age of female students.

Knowledge Questionnaire: Students’ knowledge will be assessed by 34-item, self-administered questionnaire (including sub-scales on healthy lifestyle, healthy diet, physical activity, selfidentification, relaxation activity and coping). The questionnaire was developed and modified based on previous studies [50-57]. The knowledge questionnaire consisted of five multiple-choice questions that the fifth is “I do not know” and rest of four choices is facts which only one of them is a true answer.

Attitude Questionnaire: The questionnaire on attitude included 31 items (on healthy lifestyle, healthy diet, physical activity, self-identification, relaxation activity and coping), with 5-point scale response options, ranging from ‘strongly agree (1 point)’ to ‘strongly disagree (5 points)’. It was developed based on previous studies [49-62] by the study team.

Eating Behavior Questionnaire: The Eating behavior questionnaire was developed and modified based on two preexisting questionnaires: Eating Behaviors Questionnaire (EBQ) (62) and food habits [53]. This questionnaire assessed frequency of meal consumption and snacking between meals; frequency of eating outside, fast foods, sweet foods and beverages, and frequency of food groups (fruits, vegetables, dairy and fish), type of snacks consumption, use and type of dietary supplement. The questionnaire according to the goal of intervention was modified adding questions related to ‘frequency of food groups’ Frequencies ranged from every day (score 7) to less than once a month or never (score 0). Internal consistency for the current study is 0.791. Skipping at least one meal per day will be considered as skipping meal and snacking.

Daily Activity Questionnaire: This questionnaire which was developed and validated by Kelishadi et al. [63], included 9levels of physical activity, ranging from inactivity (0.9 METs) to vigorous activity (>6 METs). The cronbach’s alpha value of the scale was 0.87, which indicates acceptable internal consistency.

Coping Inventory for Stressful Situations (CISS): CISS is developed by Endler and Parker [64] and focused on identification and comparison of basic coping strategies used by different individuals across different types of stressful situations [64]. The CISS is a 48-item scale that measures three basic coping strategies: Task-Oriented, Emotion-Oriented, and Avoidance (distraction and social items), with 16 items per scale. These 5-point Likert scales are scored from 1 (not at all) to 5 (very much). The higher summing scores indicate a greater use of that particular coping strategy. The Cronbach’s alpha reported for the scale and its sub-scales range from 0.72 to 0.92 [64]. The Persian version of the CISS was validated [65] with the Cronbach’s alpha of 0.70 to 0.86 for coping scales.

General Health Questionnaire-28 (GHQ-28): The GHQ-28 was developed and validated by Goldberg and Hillier [66] to detect the risk of developing psychiatric disorder or to measure emotional distress. The questionnaire is consisted of 28 questions in 4 Likert scale from 0 (not at all) to 3 (much more than usual). The scores above 22 indicate disorder symptoms. The Cronbach’s alpha coefficient of the Persian version of GHQ is 0.90 [67].

Relaxation Activity: This questionnaire was developed based on the frequency of practicing relaxation activity techniques for muscle relaxation activity and deep breathing activity according to the literature review [49,68,69]. Two questions on the duration and frequency of doing relaxation will assess the relaxation activities. The frequency of relaxation activities was including: none, 1 time, 2 or 3 times, 4 or 5 times, 6 or 7 times. The scores was ranging from 0 (none) to 4 (6 or 7 times). Total relaxation activity practice per week was calculated as the sum of the two individual behaviors per week.

Data Collection Procedure

Data will be collected using a set of structured, pre-tested and self-administrative questionnaires in Persian language. After identifying appropriate schools, the agreements will be done by telephone and face to face meeting with the schools’ principals. The principals of the 12 selected schools were informed about the objectives of the study and how the process of data collection would be. After obtaining the approval from the school principal, participants and their parents will be given consent forms one week before data collection and they will be asked to return back the signed consent forms. The principal and teachers of the school will inform the students of the data collection process. After making an appointment for baseline data collection, the self-administered questionnaires will be handed to participants to be filled out in the classes. First, research team will explain all questionnaires step by step to participants and will ask them to complete the questionnaires truly. After filling the questionnaires, the anthropometry measurements, including body weight and height will be measured using calibrated tools by research team.

The educational sessions will be commenced in 5 months (September-January). A baseline data will be collected a week prior to the intervention and subsequently an immediate post-test and a three-month follow-up test will be carried out for both groups (control and intervention) using the same questionnaire set.

Expected Outcomes: The expected study outcomes including the primary and secondary outcomes which will be implemented in sequence are presented in Table 2.

Table 2: The primary and secondary outcomes of the study.

Data Analysis

Data will be analyzed using the SPSS software version 21.0. Normality of data will be checked by the value of skewness/std. error less than 1.96, and histogram values. For data which are not normally distributed, a log transformation can be used. The alpha level at 0.05 will be taken as the level of statistical significance for all the variables in the analysis. Independent t-test will be done to determine the differences in the mean between intervention and control groups. For the nominal and ordinal variables, Chisquare test will be used to test the association between categorical dependent and independent variables. Two-way repeated measure ANOVA controlling for baseline socio-demographic data, will be performed to test whether there is significant difference in the means score between study groups at different times over the period of study and also for the effect of time (baseline, at 3 months and 6 months follow-up assessments) in each group.

Discussion

This paper presents the rationale and protocol for the healthy lifestyle intervention among adolescents. To the best our knowledge, this is an innovative intervention and the first randomized lifestyle change educational program, using three main domains of stress management, diet and physical activity. Other studies tried to introduce lifestyle to adolescents and/or adults conducting physical activity and healthy diet [70,71]. Conducting the trial in schools with different socio-economical levels is important to evaluate feasibility and effectiveness of the intervention. As far as some lifestyle skills may be improved in poverty and some in wealth [72,73]. Moreover, adolescents meet lots of crises in the specific period of life while have a bit skills to solve or manage them. Targeting adolescents that do not have enough information about themselves and their health is one of the crucial requirements for each country to have healthy society in future. Poor knowledge on lifestyle can lead to poor health and subsequently psychosocial problems and/or poor diet which are the major problems among adolescents especially in urban settings [74]. Although these issues have often been neglected, early intervention can prevent and improve emotional disturbances. Paying attention to factors related to adolescent mental health, lifestyle and dietary behavior is an urgent necessity. Improving mental health will require increasing knowledge, changing attitude and improving stress management skills, diet quality and physical activity [43,75,76], as the components of healthy lifestyle [77,78].

Previous studies have mainly focused on coping strategies to deal with negative emotions such as stress, sadness, and anxiety [79,80], while in the current study, positive approach to stress management is emphasized, including active coping, getting consultation from wise people, teachers and parents, role playing to find solutions for different difficulties, as well as relaxation activities. For instance, the coping strategies included in the module involved activities such as improving children’s abilities, feelings, communications, and networking to help them cope more effectively with changes in life. And also each session will be continued by performing physical activity or exercise to improve mental health even in the presence of serious mental problems [81]. Finally, increasing knowledge and improving attitude and behaviour on healthy diet aims to reduce stress oxidative and boost mental health as well as reduce the risk of mental disorders. Through the proposed intervention, fruits, vegetables, whole brans, fish, and also dairy products and water are promoted as a mean to reduce stress. In line with this approach, O’Neil et al. [82] proposed a dietary intervention to improve mental health. Their protocol involved some dietary changes, including eating fruits, vegetables, whole grains, fish, olive oil, legumes and nuts. A study by Kulkarni et al. [83] showed that healthy eating was significant associated with mental health and unhealthy eating was associated with mental distress (p<0.05). Contrary, a descriptive study among middle-aged individuals stated that healthy diet had no significant associated with mental health [84].

However, although programs on improving healthy diets, physical activities and psychosocial wellbeing are being implemented among adolescents, comprehensive approaches on healthy lifestyle considering its main components in one package is still rare. Accordingly, the findings of this study will be useful for health educators, health promoters, and nutritionists who provide an opportunity to impress adolescents’ requires such as coping, eating and physical activities. In addition, the educational program can be used for future interventions which are based on behavioral changes. The findings of this study will provide useful information for policy makers in this area to focus on interventional strategies that will address behavioral changes among adolescents to improve mental health.

Timeline and The Current Status of the Trial

The research study will be conducted over more than one year comprising preparation of the educational package, pilot study, and implementation of study, data analysis and writing the report. Permissions and recruitment of participants commenced in winter 2018.

Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate

The project got ethic approval from the ethical committee of faculty of nutritional sciences and food technology, Shahid Beheshti Medical University, coded IR.SBMU.nnftri.1395.199. In addition, the ministry of education of Iran, educational offices of 6 districts of Tehran city, principals of 12 secondary schools, teachers, students and their parents will be informed about the objectives of the study. Moreover, written consent forms will be signed by the students and their parents before beginning of data collection.

Competing Interest

There is no competing interest for authors.

Acknowledgements

We would like to express our sincere gratitude to managements and teachers of schools for their valuable cooperation.

References

Review Article

Development of a Healthy Lifestyle Module to Improve Mental Health in Adolescent Students: Protocol of a Randomized Controlled Trial

Esra Tajik*1, Nasrin Omidvar2, Mohammadreza Mohammadi3 and Behnam Rashidkhani4

Author Affiliations

1Psychiatry and psychology research center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences and Department of Community Nutrition, National Nutrition and Food Technology Research Institute, Faculty of Nutrition and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Iran

2Department of Community Nutrition, National Nutrition and Food Technology Research Institute, Faculty of Nutrition and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Iran

3Psychiatry and psychology research center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences

4Department of Community Nutrition, Faculty of Nutrition and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Tehran, Iran

Received: May 15, 2021 | Published: May 24, 2021

Corresponding author: Esra Tajik, Psychiatry and psychology research center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences and Department of Community Nutrition, National Nutrition and Food Technology Research Institute, Faculty of Nutrition and Food Technology, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Science, Iran

DOI: 10.26717/BJSTR.2021.36.005787

Abstract

The current study aimed to determine if a lifestyle-based intervention program could improve the mental health of adolescent students. This study is a randomized controlled trial in eleven sessions among 370 adolescents with no severe score of general health questionnaire. Primary outcome assessment at pre-, post- and three-month followup tests includes general health score and the secondary outcomes include changes in eating habit, physical activity and stress management skills using healthy lifestyle questionnaire, eating behavior, daily activity, coping inventory for stressful situations and general health questionnaire. The findings of the current study will be used as a starting point of incessant, regular lifestyle education for adolescents, and for researchers and educators to improve the health and well-being globally.

Keywords: Healthy Lifestyle; Healthy Eating; Mental Health; Depression; Anxiety; Stress